The DPLIA method
The Digital Public Law Framework and DPLIA
An analytical, soft-law framework that combines the Power over Code standard and the Digital Public Law Impact Assessment (DPLIA).
- Functional Scope TestDecides whether Digital Public Law applies.
- Six-Layer Governance ArchitectureShows where legality and accountability are kept or lost.
- Private Actor TestDecides when private involvement in public power triggers scrutiny.
- Constitutional InfrastructureDigital infrastructure that rights or institutional continuity rely on.
- Non-Delegable Public ResponsibilityHanding over a task does not hand over responsibility for it.
- Digital Public Law Impact AssessmentA lifecycle method for anticipating and governing constitutional risk.
- Constitutional and legal-regulatoryMandate, statutory authority, proportionality, rights.
- Institutional responsibilityCompetence, delegation, procurement, vendors.
- Data and infrastructureRegistries, digital identity, cloud, cybersecurity.
- Decision and service deliveryAlgorithms, discretion, human oversight, interfaces.
- Accountability and oversightReasons, audit, appeals, judicial review, remedy.
- Resilience and continuityFailure, cyber incidents, manual fallback, exit.
- Functional substitutionThe private actor performs a task the public institution would otherwise perform, or without which the function could not lawfully continue.
- Practical indispensabilityThe institution depends on the actor so deeply that the actor's conduct can decide whether the function keeps operating lawfully.
- Accountability displacementThe usual duties to give reasons, and the usual review and remedies, do not reach the private actor.
- Non-delegable public responsibilityThe test is met. The institution must keep access to documentation, audit rights, control over material changes, evidence and an exit route.
- Strategic conceptionDefine objectives and legal basis
- Design and procurementChoose architecture and suppliers
- Development and deploymentBuild and launch the system
- Operational governanceMonitor and manage operations
- Review and adaptationReassess and update the system
- Termination or transitionWithdraw or replace the system
How an assessment runs
- Step 1ScopeFunctional Scope Test: is public authority being exercised?
- Step 2Function mapActors, data, vendors and dependencies
- Step 3Six GatesThe legal tests, in order
- Step 4Causal synthesisHow a defect would travel through the system
- Step 5Institutional decisionTaken and owned by the institution
- Step 6Lifecycle reviewRe-assessed as the system changes
The Six Gates
- Lawful Mandate
- Rights-Justified Design
- Public Responsibility
- Operational Control
- Evidence, Review and Remedy
- Continuity and Exit
The ten retained capabilities
Non-delegable public responsibility, made testable: capabilities the responsible institution must actually hold, not merely assert.
- Understand
- Direct
- Document
- Audit
- Explain
- Correct
- Intervene
- Preserve evidence
- Continue
- Exit
Alongside HUDERIA
The Council of Europe's HUDERIA assesses impacts on human rights, democracy and the rule of law. DPLIA adds the constitutional-legality and institutional-control layer and is designed to be used with it.
Alongside ISO/IEC 42001
A management-system audit asks whether an organisation governs its AI well. DPLIA asks whether a public institution keeps lawful control of a specific function. The two answer different questions.
Alongside the AI Act FRIA
An Art. 27 fundamental rights impact assessment is a deployer's own document. DPLIA can sharpen its scope, affected-persons and oversight sections without replacing it.
Power over Code: Digital Public Law Standard, Consultation Draft v1.0. Prepared by the Institute. Not yet adopted or endorsed by EPLO.