Skip to main content

The DPLIA method

Method

The Digital Public Law Framework and DPLIA

An analytical, soft-law framework that combines the Power over Code standard and the Digital Public Law Impact Assessment (DPLIA).

DigitalPublic Law Functional Scope TestDecides whether DigitalPublic Law applies. Six-Layer GovernanceArchitectureShows where legality andaccountability are kept or lost. Private Actor TestDecides when private involvementin public power triggers scrutiny. ConstitutionalInfrastructureDigital infrastructure that rightsor institutional continuity rely on. Non-Delegable PublicResponsibilityHanding over a task does nothand over responsibility for it. Digital Public LawImpact AssessmentA lifecycle method for anticipatingand governing constitutional risk.
  • Functional Scope TestDecides whether Digital Public Law applies.
  • Six-Layer Governance ArchitectureShows where legality and accountability are kept or lost.
  • Private Actor TestDecides when private involvement in public power triggers scrutiny.
  • Constitutional InfrastructureDigital infrastructure that rights or institutional continuity rely on.
  • Non-Delegable Public ResponsibilityHanding over a task does not hand over responsibility for it.
  • Digital Public Law Impact AssessmentA lifecycle method for anticipating and governing constitutional risk.
The six original concepts of Digital Public Law. The Functional Scope Test decides whether the field applies; the other five organise the analysis once it does.

How an assessment runs

  1. Step 1ScopeFunctional Scope Test: is public authority being exercised?
  2. Step 2Function mapActors, data, vendors and dependencies
  3. Step 3Six GatesThe legal tests, in order
  4. Step 4Causal synthesisHow a defect would travel through the system
  5. Step 5Institutional decisionTaken and owned by the institution
  6. Step 6Lifecycle reviewRe-assessed as the system changes

The Six Gates

  1. Lawful Mandate
  2. Rights-Justified Design
  3. Public Responsibility
  4. Operational Control
  5. Evidence, Review and Remedy
  6. Continuity and Exit

The ten retained capabilities

Non-delegable public responsibility, made testable: capabilities the responsible institution must actually hold, not merely assert.

  • Understand
  • Direct
  • Document
  • Audit
  • Explain
  • Correct
  • Intervene
  • Preserve evidence
  • Continue
  • Exit

Alongside HUDERIA

The Council of Europe's HUDERIA assesses impacts on human rights, democracy and the rule of law. DPLIA adds the constitutional-legality and institutional-control layer and is designed to be used with it.

Alongside ISO/IEC 42001

A management-system audit asks whether an organisation governs its AI well. DPLIA asks whether a public institution keeps lawful control of a specific function. The two answer different questions.

Alongside the AI Act FRIA

An Art. 27 fundamental rights impact assessment is a deployer's own document. DPLIA can sharpen its scope, affected-persons and oversight sections without replacing it.

Power over Code: Digital Public Law Standard, Consultation Draft v1.0. Prepared by the Institute. Not yet adopted or endorsed by EPLO.